Every now and then, I get the chance to dive into something fresh, and this time it’s a Sapatero shoes review. Sapatero is a brand from the Philippines producing classic dress shoes in French calf leather with proper welted construction. They sent me two models to explore: the Castillo double monk and the Francisco Oxford. Both are black, both are made from French calf, and both are priced around $440. I have been wanting to see their shoes for a while now, so I’m glad that the time is finally here!
First Impressions & Packaging
Sapatero impressed me immediately with their presentation. The box is sturdy and lined with a quilted pattern, featuring the brand’s clever hammer logo — a subtle nod to the craft of shoemaking while tying it into their name as the hammers created an ‘S’. Even the wrapping paper is printed with shoe design sketches, something I’ll always appreciate as a designer myself. A shoe care guide card is also included, which is a thoughtful touch for clients.
That said, I do think one detail was missing: dust bags. For shoes in this price category, dust bags are essential. Without them, the pairs arrived with some scuffs on the toes — nothing permanent, but not ideal for presentation.
I also filmed an unboxing, which you can watch below:
Design & Construction
Both the Castillo and Francisco are built on Vibram soles with leather welts, striking a balance between comfort and durability. I was pleasantly surprised by how lightweight they felt for Vibram, as some rubber-soled shoes can be heavy. Finishing is kept straightforward — you won’t find decorative welt fudging or beveled waists — but the focus here is on practicality and wearability.
What stood out most was the last shape. Sapatero describes it as Italian, but I’d say it has more of a French influence — a round last with elegant, slightly angular proportions. It reminds me of Gaziano & Girling’s DG70, but with its own flair. The result is a balanced, sharp profile that looks refined without being overly pointed.
Fit & Comfort of the Sapatero Shoes
Fit is where I found an interesting difference between the two models. Although both pairs are built on the same last in the same size (41), the Castillo double monk fit me better than the Francisco Oxford. My guess is that the monk was graded with a lower instep, giving me a closer fit, while the Oxford’s short facing left little room to tighten the laces.
Even so, both shoes offered something I rarely find in dress shoes at this price: excellent arch support. Combined with the Vibram sole, these are shoes you can wear comfortably throughout the day — something not all welted dress shoes can claim. A big thumbs up here for the Filipino shoemaker.
Value & Verdict of the Sapatero Shoes Review
At roughly $440, Sapatero sits in the competitive mid-tier welted shoe category. For the price, you’re getting French box calf leather, a solid construction, a smart last, and impressive comfort. The main drawbacks are the missing dust bags, some minor shipment scuffs, and outsole finishing that’s fairly standard.
But what makes Sapatero stand out is not just the product, but the people behind it. One of the founders, JR, is a trained shoemaker who once attended one of my trunk shows in Dallas as a guest and even bought one of my sneakers, which was a real flattering moment. He also entered a shoe in the World Championship of Shoemaking that stood out to me for its design. These are the kinds of passionate craftsman I want to support.
If you’re looking for a brand that combines Filipino shoemaking, French calf leather, and genuine comfort, this Sapatero shoes review should make it clear: they’re worth a serious look.
Learn more here: https://sapatero.com/
—Justin FitzPatrick, The Shoe Snob
Shop · Marketplace · J.FitzPatrick · Patreon
